Revision Actionability

{
  "student_text": "Some people think AI-powered pets are a good alternative to real pets because they could help around the house etc.",
  "feedback_text": "You're right, the AI pets could help around the house. Can you find some other details from the article that you could add to make your claim stronger?"
}

{
  "reasoning": "The student gives a vague reason ('less of a responsibility') without specific text-based support, so revision is needed. The feedback affirms the idea and adds related context, but names no action the student could take — it does not provide a usable next step.",
  "key_features": {
    "directive_verb_or_focused_question": {
      "met": "no",
      "justification": "Affirms the student ('That's right') and adds a comment, but contains no directive verb or focused question prompting revision."
    },
    "clarity_of_target": {
      "met": "no",
      "justification": "Does not identify any part of the response to revise."
    },
    "specificity_of_next_move": {
      "met": "no",
      "justification": "Names no concrete action the student could take."
    },
    "reasonable_student_action": {
      "met": "no",
      "justification": "The student is left without a clear sense of what to change or add."
    }
  },
  "proposed_adjustment": "Add a directive verb or focused question. Example: 'That's a reason from the article. Can you add a specific example of what the article says makes AI pets less of a responsibility?'",
  "actionable_revision_score": "no"
}